Showing posts with label health. Show all posts
Showing posts with label health. Show all posts

Monday, May 5, 2008

Scary TV.

I watch Grey's Anatomy, and I'm not going to lie, it's one of my favorite guilty pleasures. But I just caught up on last week's episode ("Piece of My Heart") and there was a line that jumped out at me. When Izzy is talking to the HIV+ woman who has just found out that she's pregnant and wants an abortion. And yes, the point is that Izzy does a terrible job of explaining to the woman that with treatment, her child could be born free of HIV, and the moral of the story is that Izzy realizes this and provides the woman with this information. But in the middle of it all, she throws in this line: "If you want to have an abortion because you want to have an abortion, then that's between you and whatever God you believe in."

I recognize that logic. "Sin if you will, it's not my problem. That's between you and God. But I think I know what he might have to say about that." So Izzy says that she's not pushing an agenda, but there's still judgment and shaming involved. It was chilling coming from a doctor. Even if it's only a doctor of the perpetually-distracted-by-personal-drama-during-surgery, knockin'-boots-in-the-on-call-room, cutting-Denny's-LVAD-wire variety.

Sunday, May 4, 2008

Hero complexes.

Watching a segment on Paul Farmer on 60 Minutes... Since reading Mountains Beyond Mountains a few years ago, my first reaction to anything having to do with Paul Farmer is always positive. But I'm instinctively suspicious of how 60 Minutes might decide to portray him and his work and the issues.

...pause to finish watching the segment...

My first thought is that I sorta want to read Mountains Beyond Mountains again. Because when I read it the first time, I was so fundamentally moved and inspired. Not only by his vision and his understanding of what the right to health means (that no one should be denied the right to health care because of the poverty that results from the accident of their birth) but the network of people that were attracted to that vision and who helped him to build it.

And Paul Farmer is an inspiring person, if only because of his strategy for building his organization or for making it possible to deliver health care. In the 60 Minutes segment, they talk about how Partners in Health, the organization he co-founded, will survive after he is gone because it is run by Haitian physicians in Haiti and Rwandan physicians in Rwanda and so on. PIH depends on community health workers to reach out to patients living in rural or difficult-to-reach areas. So in the end, it's not really about Paul Farmer. His vision would never have come about if there wasn't an army of people equally committed to that vision.

But we can never talk about it that way. By "it," I suppose that I mean Changing the World or however we might put it. It's why we talk about any great change in terms of the great people who represented that change. So Martin Luther King, Jr. becomes a stand-in for the civil rights movement, or Mandela for the anti-apartheid movement, or Gandhi for the independence movement. And we forget that the change they represent would have meant nothing without a mass movement of people who believed in the same ideas.

It's more exciting to tell a "hero" story, though. About the strength of an individual who changes the course of history. And the reality is not quite as "sellable." That change comes about in usually mundane ways, created by people who will be generally forgotten.